The Ordinary Salicylic Acid 2% Masque Face Moisturizer for Oil Control & Pore Congestion vs Dot & Key Watermelon Cool Icy Plunge Clay Mask

Two products people often weigh against each other. Here is what separates them.

	The Ordinary Salicylic Acid 2% Masque Face Moisturizer for Oil Control & Pore Congestion	Dot & Key Watermelon Cool Icy Plunge Clay Mask
Suits	acne-prone, combination, oily	acne-prone, combination, oily
Best for	Clogged pores Blackheads and whiteheads Oily T-zone Occasional breakouts	Oily skin Congested pores Refreshing dull skin Cooling sensation
Avoid if	Dry or sensitive skin Open wounds or broken skin Using other strong exfoliants	Very dry skin Sensitive skin to menthol Allergy to clay or fruit extracts Contains fragrance — patch test if you have fragrance sensitivity
Reviewers like	Reduces blackheads and whiteheads Leaves skin smooth and clean Controls sebum and oiliness	Provides a cooling and soothing sensation Reduces acne and blemishes Leaves skin feeling clean and refreshed
Reviewers dislike	Quantity is less for the price Can be harsh if left on too long	Consistency is thick and dries quickly, making it hard to spread Can dry out skin for some users
Problems reported	—	—

Still torn?

Tell Miyu about your skin and it will pick between these two for you.