Minimalist Marula Oil 05% Cleansing Oil vs Pilgrim French Red Vine Supermelt Cleansing Balm

Two products people often weigh against each other. Here is what separates them.

	Minimalist Marula Oil 05% Cleansing Oil	Pilgrim French Red Vine Supermelt Cleansing Balm
Suits	dry, normal, sensitive	all, combination, dry, normal, oily, sensitive
Best for	Removing waterproof makeup First step of double cleanse Dry skin needing gentle cleanse Non-stripping cleansing	Removing heavy makeup First step of double cleansing Dry skin needing gentle cleanse
Avoid if	Oily skin prone to breakouts Acne-prone skin Allergy to olive or jojoba oil	Prefer foaming cleansers Very oily skin (may feel heavy)
Reviewers like	Provides ample hydration and softness Effective for dry skin, resolving issues like white patches and acne Cleansing oil effectively removes waterproof makeup and sunscreen	Hydrates and nourishes skin overnight Absorbs quickly without feeling greasy or sticky Improves skin texture, making it smooth and soft
Reviewers dislike	Can feel slightly oily and sticky for some users Not recommended for daytime use or oily skin types due to dewy finish	—
Problems reported	—	—

Still torn?

Tell Miyu about your skin and it will pick between these two for you.