Miyu

Kiehl's Rare Earth Mask vs Mamaearth Charcoal Purifying Face Pack Detoxifies, Deep Cleanses, Minimizes Pores & Brightens Skin

Both are picks in Miyu's guide Best face mask for acne-prone skin in India. Here is what separates them.

Kiehl's Rare Earth MaskMamaearth Charcoal Purifying Face Pack Detoxifies, Deep Cleanses, Minimizes Pores & Brightens Skin
Suitsacne-prone, combination, oilyoily, combination, acne-prone
Review sample30 reviews read30 reviews read
Best for
  • Oily skin with clogged pores
  • Reducing shine
  • Detoxifying skin
  • Deep cleansing pores
  • Detoxifying skin
  • Brightening dull skin
  • Minimizing large pores
Avoid if
  • Dry skin
  • Very sensitive skin
  • Skin prone to redness
  • Very dry skin
  • Sensitive skin (charcoal can be strong)
Reviewers like
  • Makes skin soft, fresh, and glowing
  • Removes impurities
  • Good for oily and acne-prone skin
  • Deep cleanses and purifies skin, removing dirt and oil
  • Leaves skin feeling soft, smooth, and refreshed
  • Brightens skin and helps reduce blackheads/breakouts
Reviewers dislike
  • Price is very high for the quantity
No usable data in the review sample
Problems reportedNone reported by 2 or more reviewersNone reported by 2 or more reviewers

Still torn?

Tell Miyu about your skin and it will pick between these two for you.

Ask Miyu